Not-for-Profit, Award-Winning Community News and Views for Windham County, Vermont • Since 2006
Voices / Letters from readers

Let’s dispense with the faux handwringing over the Palestinians

RE: “Not my homeland” [Viewpoint, May. 23]:

Here are two things I agree with in Laura Perlstein’s Viewpint:

Criticism of Israel does not amount to anti-Semitism, and that the lessons of the Holocaust are also lessons in human dignity and a respect for life.

But it is hard for me to reconcile some of her other statements particularly as it relates to history.

She is a teacher and librarian, and I am surprised her research and learning is so limited.

How stunning it is for me to read her statement pertaining to the last 70 years in the Middle East.

How could it be that you do not remember that the Mullah in Palestine heavily supported Hitler? He told the Palestinians to get out of Jerusalem until “they” destroyed the new state.

And how can you forget that in 1948 the Palestinians were offered a state of their own? How can you forget what happened next?

And didn’t they tell you in Sunday school that there has always been a Hebrew presence in Jerusalem for millennia? Maybe not on your map.

You do remember, I hope, the cry and plea, at Passover Seders — next year in Jerusalem. I guess this means nothing to you today.

There is plenty of room for discussion, conversation, and attempts to solve the problems created by years dedicated by the Palestinians and other Arab nations to destroy Israel, and we know of Israel’s response.

Let’s have some truth in our conversation and not this faux handwringing about the rights of the Palestinians. Deep-rooted problems require more than mouthing about human rights.

It does seem to me there is a group in Brattleboro obsessed with only the plight of the Palestinians under the guise of human rights. Where have they been when there have been other threats to so many in Asia, Africa — you name it? Have they been staging protests for those forgotten people?

It just makes me suspicious of what the real agenda is about.

Is there a double standard here? Is it okay for Christians and other religions to be oppressive, but not okay for the Jews?

Selma Schiffer
Wilmington

What do you think? Leave us a comment

Editor’s note: Our terms of service require you to use your real names. We will remove anonymous or pseudonymous comments that come to our attention. We rely on our readers’ personal integrity to stand behind what they say; please do not write anything to someone that you wouldn’t say to his or her face without your needing to wear a ski mask while saying it. Thanks for doing your part to make your responses forceful, thoughtful, provocative, and civil. We also consider your comments for the letters column in the print newspaper.

Add Comment

* Required information
1000
What is the day after Friday?
Captcha Image
Powered by Commentics

Comments (6)

Sort By
Topic: Page One
5/5 (2)
1 2 > Last
Gravatar
New
Amelia Stone
Gravatar
1
0
0
Aug 2018
Amelia Stone (E Dummerston, Vermont, US) says...

Kudos to the Boston Globe for encouraging newspapers across the country to remind us all of the value of a free press, and to the Commons for hearing that call. The NYTimes article, A Free Press Needs You, concludes with the following: \"If you haven’t already, please subscribe to your local papers. Praise them when you think they’ve done a good job and criticize them when you think they could do better. We’re all in this together.\" Today I plan to subscribe.

Gravatar
New
Bev Matias
Gravatar
1
1
0
Aug 2018
Bev Matias (Connecticut, US) says...

Thank you for your efforts to disseminate the news of the day and resist the hate-filled and deceitful rhetoric of this administration. I cannot believe, still, in this country that it is necessary for the press and regular citizens to defend themselves. Only one quarter or less of the citizens believe a word he says yet you are forced to defend yourselves because his speech is so incediary. The press is now officially our last line of defense.

Gravatar
New
Janet
Gravatar
1
1
0
Aug 2018
Janet (Venice, Florida, US) says...

You nailed it perfectly.

Gravatar
New
banar Singleton
Gravatar
1
2
0
Aug 2018
Most Likes
banar Singleton (Michigan, US) says...

Spot on...thank you for challenging those who would blanketly dismiss your opinion/facts to do their own \"facts checking\". Unfortunately I fear many if not most of these sheep will be lead to slaughter thinking that they are going to the trough.

Gravatar
New
Scott
Gravatar
1
0
1
Aug 2018
Scott says...

Foreign hand on the scale isn’t an unbiased conclusion. You argument might be more forceful without highlighting this issue.

Page 1 of 2
1 2 > Last
 
 

Originally published in The Commons issue #463 (Wednesday, June 13, 2018). This story appeared on page D3.

Related stories

More by Selma Schiffer