Would today’s training have resulted in better outcome in 2014 death?

BRATTLEBORO — I attended Sunday's demonstration in memory of George Floyd. I carried a sign reading “ask me about michael santiago.” Due to the noise and social distancing, I had little opportunity to explain.

On April 4, 2014, at 5:30 a.m., an officer of Brattleboro Police Department shot and killed Michael Santiago in a motel room at America's Best Inn during the execution of a search warrant for drugs. After breaking down the door and shouting “show your hands,” Santiago was shot twice for not complying to the satisfaction of the officer.

It turned out Santiago was unarmed. The state investigation determined the homicide was justified.

I have thought about this killing frequently over the past six years, as Michael Brown, Eric Garner, Tamir Rice, Walter Scott, George Floyd, and countless other unarmed individuals have been killed by police.

I know the Brattleboro officer who killed Santiago. He is a decent man. I worked with him on revising the police department's use of force policy after officers tased two nonviolent demonstrators on Putney Road in 2006.

My conclusion is that there is something very wrong with police training. I read Chief Fitzgerald's letter to the community after the George Floyd murder. My question to our chief is: Since the Santiago homicide, has anything changed in Brattleboro Police Department training that would allow for a better outcome?

Subscribe to the newsletter for weekly updates